La Voz

'We knew what we were doing was right'

Witnesses talk as De Anza baseball rape case is turned over to Attorney General

Sung Kim

Issue date: 6/11/07 Section: News
  • Print
  • Email
  • Page 1 of 1
De Anza soccer players April Grolle (left) and Lauren Chief Elk say they witnessed the rape of a 17-year-old girl by members of the De Anza baseball team. The women say they support the Attorney General taking over the case.
Media Credit: Chris Marks
De Anza soccer players April Grolle (left) and Lauren Chief Elk say they witnessed the rape of a 17-year-old girl by members of the De Anza baseball team. The women say they support the Attorney General taking over the case.

The State of California Attorney General's office agreed to review the rape case of a 17- year-old girl after Santa Clara County District Attorney Dolores Carr received heavy criticism for not pressing charges against members of De Anza College's baseball team.

"I want to let you know that I applaud the district attorney's decision," said De Anza College President Brian Murphy in an e-mail to campus faculty and staff. "The college welcomes the attorney general's review and another venue to ensure a full and fair resolution to this case."

Lauren Chief Elk and April Grolle, De Anza women's soccer team players, are two of the three women who witnessed and helped the victim during the night the alleged rape occurred. In an interview with La Voz Weekly, they said that they were very excited the case is moving forward.

"I think it's a good decision," said Grolle. "They also have new pieces of evidence that can be brought into the case a second time." The third witness, Lauren Breayans, is in a study abroad program in France, and was unavailable for an interview.

In early March, the women took the teenager to a hospital after they found her laying down, partially clad, unresponsive and surrounded by men at a party in San Jose.

The De Anza community, the district attorney and women's rights' organizations praised the women's actions as "brave and courageous."

"At first it was not like that though," said Grolle. "People were harassing us saying 'stop lying' and 'shut your mouth' and 'I want to see what kind of car you're driving,' because they thought we were lying to try to get people in trouble."

"And this came from people like our peers, friends and some people we didn't even know," said Chief Elk. "The police had to be called because we were getting threatened so much." Despite the ordeal and harassment, the women refused to back down. "We really didn't care because we knew what we were doing was right," said Chief Elk.

Grolle and Chief Elk also said they disagreed with a comment made by Spencer Maltbie in an interview with La Voz Weekly in April. Maltbie, one of eight players suspended from the baseball team after the party, confirmed that the party was for his birthday, and said "I don't drink or smoke." But Grolle and Chief Elk said they saw him consume alcohol during that night at the party.

According to the San Jose Mercury News, Attorney General Jerry Brown's office can ask Carr to re-evaluate the case if his office determines there was an error. If Carr continues not to press charges, then Brown's office may file charges in a state court.

Whatever the outcome, Grolle and Chief Elk said they will not give up as long as the victim wants to keep moving forward. Their bond strengthened over the months and they consider the victim as "a little sister."

Although the two women missed two weeks of school, became overwhelmed with the media attention and lost personal relationships, they said they will not stop doing the right thing. "From day one, we said we would do this. And we'll keep doing it as long as she wants," said Grolle.

"We lost friends and boyfriends, too, but even though I lost these people it doesn't matter because the most important thing to me is April, Lauren and the victim," said Chief Elk.

During the May 30 protest outside of the DA's office, the alleged victim released a statement asking for the attorney general's office to intervene.

Page 1 of 1

Article Tools

Viewing Comments 1 - 5 of 9

Gary Mitchell

posted 6/11/07 @ 1:01 PM PST

Dear La Voz,

The problem with the three soccer girls testimony is that they
only saw the very end of a situation that started hours before.
Furthermore their testimony falls apart, because they are saying the
girl was unconsconcis, but, they also said, the girl in question said "
I'm sorry", so how does and unconscious women say that, and what was she sorry for?

Additonally, several boys standing around people whom are having sex does not mean it was rape, they do not say anyone was holding this girl down, nor, is it clear if they too were drinking that night, and perhaps their recollection is a little clouded. (Continued…)

(2 replies)   Details   Reply to this comment

gary mitchell

posted 6/11/07 @ 1:12 PM PST

How do you subscribe? where on website is a log in ?

Gary Mitchell

posted 6/12/07 @ 9:06 AM PST

Sadly, these two girls think they are hero's and it is going to there head. The more they talk the more the Defense Attorney will chw them up.
Were they drinking that night? They say the girl in question was pass out, but, they also said the girl said "I'm Sorry". (Continued…)

(2 replies)   Details   Reply to this comment

lis

posted 8/22/07 @ 4:39 PM PST

I'd like to know why crimes/domestic assalt/rape against women aren't considered hate crimes?
Why aren't these crimes treated as harshly as a hate crime?
Why doesn't the system help protect those who are unable to protect themselves? I am 5'0 100lbs the size a of a 12yr old. (Continued…)

Kristina

posted 8/23/07 @ 5:56 AM PST

I noticed that the person who posted this "approval for rape" message is indeed a man. A dentist that I went to school with told us one day several years ago that "if men were being honest, they would admit that if we could get away with it, we would all rape". (Continued…)

Post a Comment

  • NOTE: Email address will not be published

Type your comment below (html not allowed)

  I understand posting spam or other comments that are unrelated to this article will cause my comment to be flagged for deletion and possibly cause my IP address to be permanently banned from this server.

Site Meter

Advertisement

Poll

What is the best next generation console?
Submit Vote

View Results

Advertisement